McCoy Pottery...a timeless design

By:  Laura Starr                                                         


Imagine having a design that was so perfect, so beautiful, and so desirable that other pottery companies felt compelled to duplicate your work.  Several potteries today are doing exactly that!  They appears to be relying on the expertise and talent of the designers who worked many years ago at McCoy Pottery.    Although some are doing this to intentionally fool buyers into thinking the pieces are the real McCoy, others are doing so simply to bring back a popular design.

  

pitcher.jpg (26006 bytes)

(Click to enlarge photo)

Left:  Fioriware pitcher vase, marked with Fioriware stamp (see below)  Right:  Original McCoy Pitcher Vase, marked #619 McCoy USA

 

On a recent visit to Zanesville, Ohio, we stopped at Fioriware, a pottery well known for their unusual mosaic tile pillars in the parking lot!  Their original works are exquisite!  Their attention to detail brings the reality of each piece to a new height.  Yet they still find a need to copy the designs of one of the masters in the pottery business.......McCoy. 

While there, we found six pieces that were made either identical or in the likeness of vintage McCoy Pottery pieces.  Below you will find a list of these items.

 
1.  Feather Bowl  (At right)
2.  Pitcher Vase  (show above)
3.  Floraline Basket with flowers
4.  Milk Pitcher - cows embossed on sides
5.  Grape stoneware pitcher
6.  Simple round planter

The colors that Fioriware uses are completely different than the original McCoys.  And Fioriware does not in any way attempt to pass these pieces off as the real McCoy.  

Each piece they make is CLEARLY marked on the bottom with the Fioriware Logo.  (See photo at left.)  These are not considered reproductions, but rather "look-a-likes". 

Although generally more well accepted, some collectors still become furious with companies that do this.  Not me.  I think we should look at it as a tribute to the pottery we have all grown to love so much!  However, I often wonder if the companies making these look-a-likes are doing themselves a terrible injustice, and showing their lack of confidence in their own original work by finding it necessary to  replicate proven designs of the past.  


I have seen a large selection of Fioriware original designs.  They are beautiful.  They have a uniqueness and flare that sets them apart from other potteries today.  Yet, they still copy the McCoy artists from long ago.  I guess this only proves that the designs of McCoy Pottery were not only beautiful, but timeless.

 

For more information on reproductions, look-a-likes and fakes, please be sure to visit our reproduction alert page!