How reliable is the US Mail?

mailbox.jpg (30551 bytes)
(click to enlarge)

The US mail (box) made by McCoy pottery was once thought to be a reliable piece to add to your collection.  Today, this isn't true.  Although the REAL McCoy mailbox wall pocket is still highly sought out by collectors, the reproduction has created much confusion.

Luckily for us, there are several easy ways to identify the REAL piece from the reproduction.

The size, as always, is a true give-a-way that a piece is not authentic.  The reproduction wall pocket is slightly smaller than the original.  The size discrepancy is created because of the way the reproduction piece is made.

  REAL Reproduction
Height 6 3/4" - 7" 6 1/4" - 6 1/2"
Colors DARK GREEN
ONLY
Green, Yellow, Pink, 
Blue, Aqua, White
Markings McCoy USA McCoy USA

The color is also an easy way to identify this piece as a reproduction.  The original piece was created ONLY in a dark green glossy glaze.  There may be a few one of a kind originals that have a different glaze on them, but they were only PRODUCED (in quantity) by McCoy Pottery with  this green glaze.  The reproduction pieces on the other hand have several different colors.  Right now, the only colors that are known are green, yellow, pink, blue and aqua.  This does not mean in any way that these are the ONLY colors that are produced...these are just the ones we know about right now.

Unfortunately, the markings on the bottom do not help in identifying a reproduction piece from a fake, as both pieces are marked, "McCoy USA".  This particular example shows the real piece with a much clearer mark, however, this is not always the case.

Looking from the back the pieces are also very similar, with no distinguishing marks to identify the real from the reproduction.

mailbottom.jpg (20631 bytes)
(click to enlarge)



NOTE:  A special thanks to Craig Nissen, co-author of McCoy Pottery: Reference & Value Guide, Vol. I, II & III  for his help and expertise, along with the photos on this page!