WARNING!

By:  Laura Starr   

It's happened again!   Another reproduction has surfaced!  Up until recently, NM collector's have been fairly safe in presuming that the pieces they find are originals.  Unfortunately, this isn't the case any more.  The NM fish flower holder had already been copied, but that appeared to be a reproduced on a smaller scale.  Even today, we have not seen swarms of them show up on eBay.  Well, unfortunately, this doesn't appear to 
be the case with the NM turtle.  Sellers offering the NM turtle, are also selling many of the other common reproduction pieces......which only leads me to believe that more and more of these will enter the market soon!  Therefore....COLLECTOR'S BEWARE! 
The people that are manufacturing these reproductions and fakes are getting quite good at it!  They should be.  They have had a lot of practice lately.  This miniature turtle is NO exception.  Without being able to actually "see" it in person and "feel" it, it is difficult to determine if it is in fact a fake.
One of the best ways I have found to determine if something I see on eBay is fake, is to look at what other pieces the person has sold.  Be sure to look at all COMPLETED auctions over the last month of so.  Become familiar with what pieces are being readily reproduced and see if that seller has sold any of these lately.  Chances are, if they are buying reproductions wholesale, they will have quite a few of them.  Also, look to see if they have sold any other pieces that are exactly like the one you are questioning.  Lets face if, if they have sold  NM turtles in the last month, chances are that they are buying them in quantity, and they are NEW!
Below are some pictures of the REPRODUCTION!  Please look these over carefully.  At this time, the most obvious difference is the glaze.  You can see from the picture that the glaze is a glossy finish.  The original miniatures were made with a MATTE finish.  Keep in mind, however, that there may be a FEW glossy originals out there.  I have seen an original "rose" colored piece that was what I would consider a glossy finish.  However, the majority of ORIGINAL pieces are matte.  Also keep in mind that the manufactures of these fakes might figure out how to produce a matte finish, at which time, this difference would not be reliable to use in identification.

(Pictures above are of the REPRODUCTION piece)

 

Pictured to the right is a side by side comparison.  The real turtle is on the top.

 

Pictured to the left is a side by side comparison.  The real turtle is on the top.

Perhaps the easiest way to see the difference is to compare the glaze COLOR with original NM pieces.  Look at the picture below and you will see quickly that one doesn't fit in.  Unfortunately, you can't always compare like this when buying.


REPRODUCTION "NM USA" Mark

Comparison Chart

 

Real

Reproduction

Height 2" 1 3/4"
Length Slightly > 4" 4"
Markings NM USA NM USA
Glaze matte GLOSSY!

Please note the chart above.   Again, as with more reproductions, the size is SLIGHTLY smaller than the original.  Other differences are also noted in the chart. This is what we have to go on for right now.  You may also find more info at the NM Miniature turtle page. If more information is found, it will be posted to this site.  

 

For more information on reproductions, please be sure to visit our reproduction alert page!